Political agitators use student voices to advance agendas

Design by Bella Murillo

Students at Boise State held their breath last week as anti-abortion activist Kristan Hawkins arrived on campus. Under a canopy outside the Student Union, photographers and videographers on Hawkins’ team set up. In front of her stood an open microphone prompting an invitation for students to challenge Hawkins and engage in a debate surrounding abortion rights. 

Before Hawkins, the university hosted the late Charlie Kirk in the spring of 2025, a right-wing political activist who popularized ‘Prove Me Wrong’ debate formats at universities. The presence of this conservative movement spans 3,500 high schools and over 1,500 college chapters throughout the country.  

The number of touring debaters connected to the organization have also continued to grow as part of TPUSA’s “Pick Up the Mic” initiative. This debate style has created harmful polarization on college campuses and throughout social media. Traveling with videographers, the debates often expose students to cyberbullying and online threats.

The morning of Hawkins’ campus visit, BABE VOTE, a non-profit, non-partisan organization aimed at registering voters, uploaded a post on Instagram urging students to disengage from the debate, explaining that these debates create sensationalized short-form content. 

The understanding of what a “faithful debate” looks like still remains unclear to many students. 

Isaac Castellano, professor and associate director for the Institute for Advancing American Values, an organization working to foster open dialogue and civic engagement, gave The Arbiter insight into what he believes goes into thoughtful debates. 

“You need people who are interested in hearing and understanding what the other side believes and thinks, and enters into those conversations with some amount of curiosity and interest,” Castellano said. “Real engagement on the question of abortion rights requires a slowed down, more deliberate and sometimes more facilitated conversation.”

Events of this style, broadcasted or recorded for the use of social media content, create hostile environments on college campuses, which do the opposite of providing meaningful conversations. Extremist debaters create hostile atmospheres, using students to advance their political agendas.

Some students as well as a member of TPUSA provided opposing arguments saying that these conversations create pathways for the use of free speech. 

“Turning Point’s signature ‘Prove Me Wrong’ events allow college students to engage with different perspectives, ask difficult questions, challenge their own assumptions and most importantly, exercise their First Amendment rights,” Caleb Perkins, vice president of TPUSA, wrote in an emailed statement to The Arbiter. “Freedom of speech is one of the most powerful rights we have, and it should be encouraged, not discouraged.”

Ethan Spade, a senior at the university spoke with Hawkins and expressed a similar mindset.

“[Debates] definitely allow for positive conversation. I think it just depends on how students are willing to go into those conversations,” Spade said. “…Disagreeing with each other and having open conversations is how we stay together as a country.”

On-campus debates have become some of the most popularized and significant forms of challenging information and standing for your values. In a politically polarized world it’s easy to feel the need to engage with political debaters.  

There are a multitude of spaces on campus that allow students to engage and interact with different ideas. Participating in open dialogue is incredibly important as college students continue to grow and shape their identities, but the reality behind political speakers is that their goal isn’t to learn or grow from the conversations. 

Arrien Deckard, club officer and financial coordinator for BABE VOTE at the university told The Arbiter the true concern was never how a student uses their free speech on campus. 

“We totally stand for the freedom of speech and we are always gonna advocate for people to use their voice and fight for what they believe,” Deckard explained. “These kinds of events don’t honor and host actual intellectual humility and collaboration for productive conversation.”

Pushing toward either side of a social extreme doesn’t benefit anybody in the conversation. Instead, they continue to create polarizing atmospheres at universities and on social media. 

Political issues have never been one-sided. To make meaningful change and decisions about what a person believes takes patience and exposure to different ideas. Debaters like Kristan Hawkins do the opposite, pushing to the extremes, leaving no room for engaging conversations on college campuses. 

The exposure to different powerful voices offers important perspectives into the political world, but marketing the events as opportunities to challenge the debaters opinion is simply dishonest. Debaters cause more harm to students in the process of advancing an agenda that was already set in stone long before the debates had even started.

This Post Has One Comment

  1. Eric

    The article says these debates expose “students to cyberbullying and online threats.” I can’t speak for every speaker or event, but a lot of the time the hostility starts with protesters. At UC Davis in 2023, protesters broke windows and threw eggs at a Charlie Kirk event. At VCU that same year, a Kristan Hawkins event was shut down after protesters shouted people down and it turned physical. At UC Berkeley last November, people were arrested for battery outside a TPUSA event. When people show up yelling and leading with hate, that’s what ends up getting clipped and joked about online.
    I sat through the whole of Kristan Hawkins’ debate event here. Both sides remained calm and civil. There was no problem, and this was not an attempt at agitating students. It was a means of conducting civil discussion of differing viewpoints.

Leave a Reply