EDITOR’S NOTE: A quote from university spokesperson Stephany Galbreaith was added to the online version of this article on Oct. 22 to give additional context regarding the now dissolved Sustainability Action Plan. At 6:06 p.m. on Oct. 23, this article was modified to clarify that while there is no longer a carbon neutrality plan at the university, the 10-Year Master Plan includes a variety of sustainability goals. Additions were also made to add clarity to the context of the Green Revolving Fund, now known by the Office of Sustainability as the Energy Efficiency Fund. A section of this article where the author implied Boise State had dropped “long-term quantifiable plans” has been removed in respect to the fact that the university had only eliminated carbon plans. A quote from Amy Parrish was also added to this article on the topic of receiving student input on the 10-Year Master Plan. This article ran in the Oct. 22 print issue of The Arbiter without these clarifications.
In the depths of Boise State University, amidst a loss in sustainability efforts, a secret group was formed. Rather than adorning themselves in mysterious cloaks, the group wore civilian clothing, armed with an ambitious mission to create centralized decision making structures to further advance the university’s efforts towards sustainability.
Formed under President Marlene Tromp in 2020, the Sustainability Governance Council (SGC) was made up of multiple committees representing categories in AASHE (Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education) STARS (Sustainability Tracking, Assessment & Rating System), a framework that measures universities across the country and their ability to increase eco-friendly efforts on campus.
According to the Sustainability Action Plan in 2023, the group was responsible for decreasing fuel consumption goals, developing a strategic plan of incorporating sustainability and setting up the university for a goal of carbon neutrality by 2050 alongside the city of Boise’s existing plan.
At the start of 2023, the council slowly dissolved when the university reorganized the group into the Office of Sustainability.
Now, three years later, the university’s current 10-year Master Plan has no mention of any carbon plans, and the previous Sustainability Action Plan made in 2023 is not anywhere on the Office of Sustainability’s website. Despite not listing carbon plans, the 10-year Master Plan does list sustainability goals including but not limited to energy efficiency, landscape stewardship and water conservation.
“Working across the campus and greater Boise communities, they have moved the needle in the right direction to improve efficiency, resiliency and sustainability,” university spokesperson Stephany Galbreaith said in an emailed statement to The Arbiter clarifying the status of the plan. “The 2023 Sustainability Action Plan named carbon neutrality by 2050 as an overarching, aspirational target, but it did not define the specific steps a true carbon neutrality plan requires. Carbon neutrality plans typically include baseline carbon emissions data and measurable emissions reduction actions.”
The integration of the Sustainability Governance Council into a new department might have been a simple change, but for students and members interested in making quantifiable change at the university it reaffirmed their voices on campus as a community and as advocates was diminishing.
“I do feel like there is places to hold the university accountable, the sustainability office takes a lot of student requests and the I know that professors are open to talk,” explained Vice President of the Environmental Club, Charlotte Konkol. “As an environmental study student and as a club member, I’m not sure exactly where to go past the sustainability office.”
While students may still have avenues to speak with members of the Sustainability Office, Konkol explained she feels these concerns aren’t addressed or taken seriously.
“For this Master Plan effort, we got a lot of student input for this. I feel like we do gather student input and it’s really hard to reach every student on campus,” said Amy Parrish, sustainability director at the university.
After the reorganization of the council, the Office of Sustainability absorbed $1 million dollars from the Green Revolving Fund, now known by the office as the Energy Efficiency Fund according to Janelle Smith, a Campus Operations spokesperson.
This pool of money is used to finance different projects on campus such as HVAC upgrades, water conservation, LED lighting and much more. Rather than acting like a one-time investment, the fund is used as an up-front payment which is then replenished by money used in utility or one-time expenses.
An individual previously on the Sustainability Governance Council told The Arbiter they had no recollection of how this money was used or where it went after the integration. The university’s lack of transparency with the fund resulted in confusion for many members of the council.
The council was made up of over 80 students, faculty, researchers, graduate students and community members. The loss of this group exemplified for many members the lack of interest in reaching a shared vision of community driven sustainability.
“The last few meetings that we had, there was some participation, but not a lot and people were very unclear of how to get involved,” explained Parrish. “They kickstarted some great sustainability initiatives on campus and then this office was created and this office is kind of taken over from that grassroots effort.”
Dr. Stephanie Capaldo, previous member of the council and faculty at the university shared the value of the program in an emailed statement to The Arbiter.
“I’m in the humanities, but I was able to collaborate with the treasury controller, librarians, faculty from COBE and staff from Material Sciences,” Dr. Capaldo said. “The experience was a genuine practice in shared governance… The collaborative framework modeled the ways sustainability projects are intended to function.”
Without the sustainability council, current students and community members now lack proper voices and communication channels with the Office of Sustainability.
“We don’t always see what’s going on behind the scenes,” President of the Environmental Club, Zoe Fragkias said. “Student voices can absolutely have a place… opportunities for sharing your thoughts aren’t well advertised and aren’t made known.”
Ruby Jensen, an active member in the club, shared a similar perspective. “I could definitely bring stuff up, but I’m not sure how active they would be in receiving it or working actively towards any of the things that I’d bring up.”
As a leading player in Boise’s landscape, fueling student and communal engagement is necessary. Removing collaborative frameworks, quantifiable goals and lack of financial transparency creates an atmosphere opposed to progression, pushing students three steps back in the process.
If Boise State expects continuous student and campus improvement, they must start leading by example.